I've been a fan of Sushi of Gari for a while, Seki is a protege of Gari-san, hence the style is very similar. I haven't been to Sushi Seki until a few weeks ago (apologies in advance if the descriptions aren't clear, I had a difficult time understand the server).
I went with three other friends and we did the chef's tasting menu (omakase). We started a trio of tuna, fluke & salmon. All three were very simply-prepared, I was a bit disappointed because I was expecting a very avant-garde sushi experience since I am familiar with Sushi of Gari's menu, and I thought what we got was rather "safe".
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d1f13/d1f13045ad322c1a10271532ea3db507ab6c4107" alt=""
Things took a turn for the better with the salmon with avocado & seaweed. The crispy seaweed on top gave it a great contrast to the texture.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2d09d/2d09d4ef26ba77c147c12c2d9d7f654bfd2e9cfa" alt=""
The next piece of sushi made me want to scream in ecstacy. It was sauteed buttered whitefish. Holy sushi-o-la, the fish had a really fragrant smokey taste to it, and it disintegrated in my mouth. It was buttery, warm, soft and definitely not something I've had in Gari.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9e822/9e82268708b2cc44e703e7478741c34a15ee2fe5" alt=""
The next piece was also excellent, it was tuna with sauteed onions. The onions really gave it a kick to the flavor, great combination.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e6756/e67560e605adab766ef28a61ba05e5beb379a263" alt=""
Then came the oysters handroll, the oyster tempura was excellent.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd54e/fd54e6e9dac5ed753ba398f85b2d25ff2b602308" alt=""
Feeling like we still had space in the stomach, we asked for more pieces. They gave us uni, torched toro & seared eel with avocado. Again, loved the oysters the most, the creamy sauce was a big plus.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fecd9/fecd939f710e2836c4a59f208a36e6dc73fd8fc7" alt=""
Lastly, they gave us the yummy sauteed whitefish again, toro & mackarel. I am not a big fan of mackerel because it's quite fishy, and they said the toro was hagashi toro and was rather rare.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2856a/2856a7c9e40b3b8f8b049a18f5c8a705b77a82e7" alt=""
We ended with three desserts, I especially loved the mochi. The ice cream tempura I thought was quite subpar because the crispy skin wasn't that crispy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/930f1/930f137b4651b516d8e3a5f2823c53c39e22fca3" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/966f1/966f135b1b86d1e89c801d02041cb805a91f1850" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c56b6/c56b65cc2e50afc841a6536c5fe013ef2fbc9888" alt=""
So Gari vs. Seki? What's the verdict? I still prefer Sushi of Gari. I think the sushi I had in Gari were slightly more creative, most pieces I had in Gari had sharper contrasts in terms of taste & texture. I think Sushi Seki is equally good in terms of food quality but might have err on the safe side in terms of creativity. I am sure I have some friends who would disagree, I think the vote is rather split down the middle. Well, when in doubt, try both! :D
Address: Sushi of Seki, 1143 1st Ave (between 62nd St & 63rd St), New York, NY 10021